Jewish American Literature

25 October 2006 Judaic American Literature- Comparison and ContrastWithin the literature of any acculturation , it is not unusual for there to be differing opinions close to the aforesaid(prenominal) or experience , even among those who possess first dig knowledge of these s and experiences . This dissent can be seen in the classic move arounds of Jewish American Literature and nowhere else is a marked disagreement more prevalent than when discussing the brain and works of Mary Antin , who believed that America is the land of opportunity for those who work hard and persevere , and Anzia Yeziereska , whose writings depicted the struggle for Jewish immigrants to find acceptance and opportunity in America only(prenominal) to be disappointed most of the time , earning her the moniker Cinderella of the Sweatshops (Chametzky , et al , 191 . In this essay , Mary Antin s short study The breathe will be examined , and countered with what Yeziereska s criticism of the tier would apt(predicate) be The end result will be a weighed down understanding of both of these individuals as well as their diametric roles in Jewish American literatureSynopsis of Antin s The LieUpon first taking a look at Mary Antin s The Lie , it has every external appearance of a classic American success story- in it , a young Jewish boy who has immigrated to America on with his family finds himself positively influenced and enriched by his encounter with a female American teacher who takes the initiative to give the boy the reading that he needs to have a stake in the American dream (Chametzky , et al , 233 . The Lie contains tout ensemble of the elements of a story of self discovery and growth .

Below the surface , only , as the title of The Lie indicates , there is something inauthentic about the action that takes place in the story , and that shortcoming is where Yeziereksa would likely find grist for criticism and disagreementAntin s Flaw Becomes Yeziereska s ArgumentFor all of the promise and transport that The Lie may provide at first glimpse , lurking just beneath the surface is , at the risk of stating the apparent , a lie that while somewhat justified , provides provoke for Yeziereska s theory that America is not equal for allThe lie that gives the story the same name , is that the father of the boy in the story lies about the age of the boy in to provide him with additional years of American schooling , which gives the boy an advantage for the die , but also shows that dishonesty can advance the American Dream , but at the same time goes against all that America represents . Furthermore , this lie can logically be used to make the argument in favor of Yeziereksa s sentiment that America has traditionally mistreated Jews , and that in for a Jew to hear equal opportunity in the United States , they must hook who they are and deny the very nature of their being . In other words , by lying to gain an education for his son , the...If you want to get a full essay, roll it on our website: Orderessay

If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .